Headlines Are For Humans, Titles Are For Robots

If you're new here, you may want to subscribe to the RSS feed for this blog. Or you can subscribe to a combined news feed for all SMM publications. Thanks for visiting!
For good SEO, choose the right title.
As we all spend more time in social media, such as Facebook, Digg, StumbleUpon or Sphinn, the ability to write catchy headlines becomes as important as it ever was. If someone skimming through a list of possible topics is intrigued by your headline, then they may dip in to find out what it’s all about. That’s why Brian Clark suggested you should be writing Magnetic Headlines. If you were using WordPress to write your blog, then you would presumably put that catchy headline in that field labelled Title. It all seems so easy, but in fact it’s a little too easy. In what follows to avoid confusion, we’ll call what appears in that WordPress Title field the Headline.
Although your Headline may be written to attract human beings, it may not work well in a search engine keyword ranking. Since the largest proportion of the traffic to your website will come via search engines, it may be worth using something that the search engine robots will find attractive. The problem is that WordPress uses the expression in that Title field in a number of different ways. It is of course used as the headline in the < H1 > heading for your blog. It is also used as the Title element in the head of your blog page. This is the text that appears in the bar across the top of the screen. If you have nominated Pretty Permalinks, then the WordPress will also use the same text to develop the URL for the post.
Creating Optimal Titles
This is where the dilemma arises. The Title in the head of the blog page is very important in search engine rankings. The URL may also have a slight effect on these rankings. Optimizing the text for search engine robots will likely produce something, which is not necessarily one of those Magnetic Headlines that was being suggested.
Luckily help is at hand from a variety of sources. For example, Stephan Spencer and his colleagues have developed SEO Title Tag 2.1.3, which allows you to specify a Title for the blog post, which can be different from the headline. A more complete solution is provided by the All in One SEO Pack PlugIn from Uberdose. This not only allows an independent title but also has a number of other useful features. Even used ‘out of the box’ with default settings the PlugIn will achieve a good part of what is needed to optimize your blog posts for the Search Engines. Katy Castro has a good description of how to use it.
Getting the Meta Description Right
An equally important element in getting search engine traffic to your blog post is the text in the Meta Description for the blog post. The All in One SEO Pack allows you to prepare a separate description for each page. If you don’t, the default is that it will take the first 155 or so characters from the start of the post and use that. That avoids a problem Google has in indexing blog posts that all have the same Meta Description. Checking your website with the Google Webmaster Tools website will tell you whether duplicate descriptions is a problem for your blog.
By writing the most engaging description of your blog post in 155 or less characters, you increase the chance that this is what Google will show in its search engine report pages (SERPs). Most such snippets are a jumble of words that Google selects to try to show that its selection may be relevant to the keyword search. A well-crafted sentence will encourage many more visitors to click through to your blog post.
Although the Keywords MetaTag is of limited value nowadays, the plug-in does allow you to specify what keywords are most appropriate. Again if you do not specify keywords, the plug-in will select keywords by default from either the categories or from any tags that post may have.
The URL Of The Blog Post
A secondary factor in the optimization of the blog post is the URL for the blog post. Selecting the Pretty Permalinks option is one important step here for a WordPress blog. Unfortunately as mentioned above, this is again derived from the Headline of the blog post. You will find the text used in the Post Slug element in the right hand column of the Edit screen. It is derived by taking the Headline of the Post, putting all letters in lower case and adding hyphens between the words. This is not something where the All in One SEO Pack PlugIn helps. However as the WordPress Codex recommends, if you want to create a more memorable URL, then you can create such a one using lower case words and hyphens. Often taking the Title you have derived for the All in One SEO Pack PlugIn and converting it will be a good way to go.
Conclusion
Users of the All in One SEO Pack PlugIn are effusive in their praise of how well it works, even using it ‘out of the box’. If at least for your more worthy blog posts, you go the extra mile by crafting individual entries for the PlugIn, then you will see a significant increase in your visitor traffic. If you want to see how such a post appears, you can check this post. The headline was of course, Headlines Are For Humans, Titles Are For Robots. However in the Title bar at the top of the screen, note the Title of the post, Write SEO Titles For High Rankings. A version of that also appears in the URL. Check the description by viewing the source code. It’s all extra effort but a very good use of your time.










March 9th, 2008 at 10:42 pm
Some things to consider
Your post title will appear in RSS feeds and get used by a large number of people giving you backlinks, even the splogs.
Social bookmark plugins will pick up the page title, not your headline
There are good reasons to make your initial headline useful for SEO, and if it is written for high CTR then it is also potentially something better to have in the SERPs as well.
March 9th, 2008 at 10:55 pm
Of course you’re right, Andy. My Headline for this post is deliberately more black and white than it needs to be to attract more interest among readers in social media. However if you see the Title and the Headline as two opportunities to tune the message, that gives extra flexibility. All I’m suggesting is that the priority target for the Title can be the robot, while the priority target for the Headline can be the human visitor.
March 10th, 2008 at 12:25 am
One great way to see high CTR on titles is to monitor forums in the niche as if the forum ranks you are able to see the cross section between members and SERP clicks on the threads title..
March 10th, 2008 at 12:37 pm
Great post and explanation. I’ll have to look into the SEO Title Tag plugin. I’ve heard a few things about it but haven’t ever taken the time to really look into it and see how useful it could be for me when I’m already running the All in One SEO Pack.
Also, thank you for the link back to my tutorial on I’m Blogging That.
March 10th, 2008 at 12:40 pm
Happy to see you here, Katy. I wouldn’t think you need the SEO Title Tag since the All in One SEO Pack does that and much more.
March 10th, 2008 at 1:23 pm
You know it’s amazing how many CMS systems don’t have the ability to create different titles, headlines and URL’s out of the box. good post.
March 10th, 2008 at 3:38 pm
Thank you, Michael. You’re right and it’s worth adding descriptions to that list since Google seems to find them important, even if they don’t affect rankings.
March 11th, 2008 at 2:16 am
Really useful post Barry. I’ve just started using WordPress with the all-in-one SEO plugin so thanks for providing the link to Katy’s post as well, that’ll really help to learn some of the finer points of using the pack.
March 11th, 2008 at 5:06 am
I’m glad you like it, Ken. I’m enthusiastic about the ability of the plugin, particularly if you put the extra effort in for your more noteworthy posts.
March 11th, 2008 at 9:45 am
[...] wurde ich in diesem Fall übrigens durch den SEO Titles-Artikel bei BPWrap. Sinngemäß vegetierte ein ähnlicher Entwurf schon längere [...]
March 11th, 2008 at 10:27 am
Barry, Great article. Your advice about focusing on the first 155 characters is something I will be sharing with my team.
And there ya go! Another useful use for Twitter (with its 142 character limit) — perfect way to practice getting to the point early.
Anita
March 11th, 2008 at 10:40 am
Thanks, Anita. You can’t guarantee that Google will choose to use your 155 characters in its snippet, but when it does it certainly gives a more enticing entry.
March 11th, 2008 at 12:36 pm
[...] Visit “Headlines Are For Humans, Titles Are For Robots” [...]
March 12th, 2008 at 2:40 am
I’ve been using James Brausch’s Glyphius to help me write headlines that search engines like. It lets me try different variations and scores them for effectiveness against its database. It even counts characters so I can optimize for Twitter or other short snippets.
March 12th, 2008 at 5:30 am
That’s interesting, Charlotte. However I’ll be looking into it to write my Titles rather than my Headlines. If I find it’s created something memorable for humans too, then I’d use the same for both. Thanks for the suggestion.
March 18th, 2008 at 5:56 pm
[...] It is also important that you bloggers out there are aware of what you need to do to make sure your blog is seen by as many people as possible. Don’t assume that your blog software is doing the job automatically, it most likely is not and your website traffic will suffer as a result, check out this article…. http://blog.cre8asite.net/bwelford/2008/03/write-seo-titles-for-high-rankings/ [...]
May 5th, 2008 at 2:55 pm
Barry, Great article! Lots of good information. Its amazing how many times I still see “Home Page” as the title for a page. Many people are still using the same meta description by default on all their pages and unfortunatley, like greywolf said, there are still some CMSs that do not allow these fields to be edited or optimized. This is a good start and explanation for some on-site SEO that is easy to understand even for the most novice of bloggers/site creators.
May 5th, 2008 at 3:18 pm
I get the title, description, etc. but do adding track backs help at all?
May 5th, 2008 at 3:30 pm
Bob, I assume you mean allowing others to track-back to your post. In effect this is a back-link to use Google’s term (Yahoo! calls it an inlink). Such links provided they’re from authoritative websites are certainly useful in gaining higher Google rankings.